Medical Malpractice leads to wrongful death 474

Wrongful death is another area of San-Diego-Personal-Injury-attorney.com

Stinnet v Tam 198 Cal.App.4th 1412 (5) (2011) Medical malpractice wrongful death trial verdict, $6M noneconomic damages, reduced to $250K, CC § 3333.2. San-Diego-Auto-Accident-lawyer Stinnet appealed, arguing rationale for MICRA in 1975 (malpractice insurance emergency) no longer exists. $250K cap is equivalent to $59K in 1975 dollars, thus is no longer rationally related to legitimate goal.  Affirmed. [1] While a law depending on certain state of facts may be attacked if those facts no longer exist , MICRA was based on state’s rational interest of reducing malpractice insurance costs.  Not court’s function to determine when constitutionally valid legislation has served its purpose. [2] Equal protection argument also fails as rationally relate to goal.  Dissent on equal protection where trial court failed to consider the evidence submitted.  San Diego personal injury attorney.

Comments are closed.